Compare a traditional and a Roth retirement account on equal terms. The thing most of these tools get wrong is the baseline: a $10,000 traditional contribution costs less than $10,000 today because it cuts this year's tax bill, while a Roth contribution of the same face value costs the full amount — so comparing them at equal face value compares unequal sacrifices and flatters the traditional side. This shows the after-tax result per unit of today's money alongside the headline balance, and at matching tax rates the two come out identical, which is the correct answer. The employer match is capped at a share of salary the way real plans work, and is taxed on both sides, because it is always pre-tax money.
| Situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Higher tax rate in retirement | Roth |
| Lower tax rate in retirement | Traditional |
| Same rate | Identical — pick on the tiebreakers |
| Maxing the contribution limit | Roth shelters more real money |
| Want no forced withdrawals | Roth IRA |
At the same tax rate now and in retirement, neither — they are mathematically identical, and this tool shows that to nine decimal places. The decision is a bet on your future rate: expect a higher rate later and Roth wins; expect lower and traditional wins. Anyone claiming one is simply better is comparing unequal contributions.
Because they compare $10,000 into each, which is not an equal sacrifice. The traditional $10,000 costs you $7,600 at a 24% rate; the Roth $10,000 costs $10,000. Compare per dollar of today's money and the difference disappears.
It is a percentage of what you put in, capped at a share of your salary. "100% up to 4%" on a $100,000 salary maxes out at $4,000 — contributing 10% earns you nothing extra from them. It is also always pre-tax money, so it is taxed on withdrawal even if your own contributions are Roth.
The match is an immediate return that nothing else matches, so get all of it first. Beyond that the question is whether the tax shelter beats your alternatives — usually yes, but the urgency is different.
Two real tiebreakers. The contribution limit is a nominal figure, so a Roth shelters more real money for the same limit — $23,000 of post-tax money is worth more than $23,000 of pre-tax. And a Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions, which matters for estate planning and for controlling taxable income in retirement.
No. It uses one rate now and one later, which is a simplification — real withdrawals are taxed across brackets, and state treatment varies. Use it to understand the direction of the decision, not as a filing document.
No. It is arithmetic in the page.
The comparison most of these tools get wrong is not the projection, it is the baseline. A traditional contribution of ten thousand dollars costs less than ten thousand dollars today, because it reduces this year's tax bill; a Roth contribution of the same face value costs the full amount. Comparing the two on equal face value therefore compares unequal sacrifices, and the traditional side comes out looking better than it is. This tool reports the after-tax result per unit of today's money as well as the headline balance, and at identical tax rates now and in retirement the two are identical to nine decimal places — which is the correct answer, because the arithmetic is genuinely symmetric. Commutativity is why: multiplying by the growth factor and by one minus the tax rate gives the same result in either order. Any tool showing a difference in that case is comparing unequal contributions. The employer match is handled separately and is the second thing usually mishandled. It is always pre-tax money regardless of which account you choose, so it sits in a traditional bucket and is taxed on withdrawal even in the Roth column — and it is capped at a share of salary rather than matching everything you contribute. "One hundred per cent up to four per cent of salary" does not mean the employer matches a ten per cent contribution; it stops at four per cent of pay, and contributing beyond that earns nothing further from them. Leaving the cap out overstates the match by whatever the excess was, which on a high contribution is most of it. Because the match is identical either way, it is excluded from the like-for-like figure and included in the headline balance, which is the only arrangement where both numbers mean what they appear to. The genuine tiebreakers — that a Roth shelters more real money for the same nominal limit, and has no required minimum distributions — are stated rather than buried, because when the rates match those are the entire decision.